Two ways to cull
AI-assisted culling looks at the shoot before you do. Narrative Select groups similar frames into scenes and shows close-ups of faces. Aftershoot detects blur and closed eyes, groups duplicates and can make a first selection for you, aimed at a number you choose. You then review and adjust.
Manual culling means you look at every frame, and the software's job is to be fast enough that it never makes you wait. RawGuard shows the full-size preview already inside each RAW and gets the next frames ready while you look at the current one, so the arrow key feels instant, even full screen.
Neither way is wrong. AI saves time on very large shoots. Culling yourself means every keeper was chosen by your own eye, and nothing is quietly hidden by a model's guess.
Side by side
| Narrative Select | Aftershoot | RawGuard | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Culling | AI-assisted: scenes, face close-ups | AI-assisted or automatic: blur, closed eyes, duplicates | You decide every frame, on Lightroom's keys |
| Card backup to two drives | Not its job: starts from photos on your computer | Not its job: starts from photos on your computer | Yes, both at once, every copy verified |
| AI editing | On Standard plans and up | Separate Edit plan | No |
| Runs on your computer | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| To Lightroom | Yes | Yes | XMP sidecars, including pick and reject flags |
| Culling price | From $10 a month, billed yearly ($15 monthly) | Select: $10 a month, billed yearly ($15 monthly) | Free during the beta; price after not announced yet |
| Free trial | Yes, no card needed | 30 days, no card needed | 30 days, until 31 December 2026 at the latest |
Prices in US dollars from Narrative's pricing page and Aftershoot's pricing guide. Narrative's $10 Lite plan doesn't include scene grouping or face close-ups; those start on Standard at $20 a month, billed yearly. Check both sites for the latest.
Where the AI cullers are stronger
- Very large shoots. With 5,000 frames or more, a grouped, pre-sorted shoot can save real time.
- Spotting technical misses like closed eyes and soft focus without opening every frame.
- AI editing in the same family of tools, if you want your edits done for you too.
Where RawGuard is stronger
- The backup comes first. Every card is copied to two drives in one pass, each copy read back and verified, with a checksum list and report. The AI cullers start after that job is done.
- Every frame is your call. No model decides what's hidden, grouped away or ranked low.
- Lightroom's keys, with Caps Lock moving you on after each rating, as in Lightroom.
- One simple app from card to keepers, with nothing to train and no AI settings to tune.
Can you use them together?
Yes. Back up and verify the card with RawGuard on the night, then open the project folder in Narrative Select or Aftershoot the next day if you want an AI first pass. They all read the same files, and the XMP sidecars carry the ratings between them.