Side by side
| Photo Mechanic | RawGuard | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Fast browsing, culling and captioning | Verified card backup, then culling |
| Copy to two drives | Yes, a primary and a secondary destination | Yes, both at once, plus an optional third |
| Each copy verified | Not described in its ingest guide, which suggests checking by hand | Every copy read back and compared, with a checksum list and report |
| Space and drive health checked first | Not described | Yes |
| Culling | Stars, colour classes and tags | Picks, rejects, stars and colour labels on Lightroom's keys |
| To Lightroom | XMP sidecars | XMP sidecars, including pick and reject flags |
| Captions and IPTC metadata | Extensive: templates, variables, code replacements | Not included |
| Rename files on import | Yes | No, camera file names are kept |
| RAW formats in the viewer | Wide support | NEF, CR2, ARW, DNG and JPEG for now (backup covers every format) |
| Computers | Mac and Windows | Windows, Mac in early beta |
| Price | $14.99 a month, $149 a year, or $299 once | Free during the beta; price after the beta not announced yet |
| Free trial | 30 days | 30 days, until 31 December 2026 at the latest |
Photo Mechanic prices are Camera Bits' Standard edition in US dollars, from their pricing page. Ingest details are from their Ingesting Photos guide. Check both for the latest.
Where Photo Mechanic is stronger
- Metadata. Captions, keywords, IPTC templates, variables and code replacements. For sports, news and event photographers who send captioned photos within minutes, nothing here comes close.
- Renaming on import, with text, variables and sequence numbers.
- Maturity. It has been used by working photographers for many years, on both Mac and Windows.
- Format support. It views a much wider range of RAW formats today. RawGuard's culling covers NEF, CR2, ARW, DNG and JPEG for now.
Where RawGuard is stronger
- Proof the backup worked. Every copy is read back from its drive and compared with the card. In Thorough mode the card is read twice. An MD5 checksum list and a backup report are saved on every drive.
- Both drives at once. Each file is read from the card once and written to both drives together, with an optional third copy.
- Checks before it starts. RawGuard makes sure the shoot fits on every drive and shows if a drive reports a health problem.
- Cards with several shoots are split by date, so you back up only the one you need.
- Lightroom's keys. P, X, U, 1–5 and 6–9 work as they do in Lightroom, and pick and reject flags travel in the sidecars to Lightroom Classic 13.2 and newer.
- A simpler app. Fewer settings to learn, because it does fewer jobs.
Which one should you choose?
If your work lives on metadata, such as captions for an agency, keywords for a stock library or renamed files for a newsroom, Photo Mechanic is built for that, and RawGuard isn't.
If you shoot weddings, portraits or events and the worry is losing a shoot, RawGuard does the part Photo Mechanic leaves to you: proving every file arrived intact on both drives before the card is formatted. Then it gets out of the way and lets you cull.
Some photographers will want both: RawGuard for the backup, Photo Mechanic for captioning. They don't get in each other's way, because both read the same folders and the same XMP sidecars.